Green Acceptance Sweet Spot & Recommendation

R_i = 50% Customer Acceptance + 50% Sustainability

Prototype Balanced Decision Rule

Green Acceptance Sweet Spot

Priority Testing Zone — illustrative demo data

Priority Concepts

#173 pts

CFG-062

Bamboo Fiber · Modern Ulos · Rp45.000

Sustainability

69/100

Customer Acceptance

77/100

Evidence Sufficiency

MEDIUM

Confidence

Low

Main Strengths

  • + strong customer acceptance
  • + strong cultural authenticity
  • + high packaging attractiveness

Main Trade-offs

  • limited empirical evidence on willingness-to-pay

Strong product attribute evidence, but no primary customer validation yet.

#272 pts

CFG-016

Recycled Kraft Paper · Batak Gorga · Rp45.000

Sustainability

67/100

Customer Acceptance

77/100

Evidence Sufficiency

MEDIUM

Confidence

High

Main Strengths

  • + strong customer acceptance
  • + strong cultural authenticity
  • + high packaging attractiveness

Main Trade-offs

  • material cost may require supplier verification

Customer Twin score is calibrated against real human validation responses.

#372 pts

CFG-024

Recycled Kraft Paper · Batak Gorga · Rp55.000

Sustainability

68/100

Customer Acceptance

75/100

Evidence Sufficiency

MEDIUM

Confidence

Low

Main Strengths

  • + strong customer acceptance
  • + strong cultural authenticity
  • + high packaging attractiveness

Main Trade-offs

  • higher price point
  • limited empirical evidence on willingness-to-pay

Strong product attribute evidence, but no primary customer validation yet.

Product Comparison

Prototype simulation results

ConceptMaterialDesignPriceSustainabilityAcceptanceDecisionNext Action
CFG-062Bamboo FiberModern UlosRp45.00069/10077/100BUYHuman Test
CFG-016Recycled Kraft PaperBatak GorgaRp45.00067/10077/100BUYPhysical Prototype
CFG-024Recycled Kraft PaperBatak GorgaRp55.00068/10075/100BUYHuman Test

Why MCDM?

The product concept space contains multiple alternatives evaluated across competing criteria. A transparent multi-criteria decision rule is therefore used for prototype screening.

Prototype method: Weighted Sum Model. Future research: AHP, data-driven weighting, or TOPSIS comparison.